Search This Blog

Friday, July 23, 2010


Last week WNPR's Jeff Cohen posted the back and forth letters of John Rose and Mayor Segarra when Rose refused to resign (the letters are below). Mayor Segarra requested letters of resignation from all department heads after he was sworn in as mayor. In the typical John Rose style, he dug his heels in and refused to resign for Mayor Segarra , who he described as the "interim" Mayor.

Rose always seemed to have an issue with his "fantasyland" interpretation of Hartford's Charter and also State and Federal laws. The letters can be read below, but as you can see from the final sentence in the last letter, Mayor Segarra was able to finally accomplish as Mayor what he couldn't do as a Council Person.

On July 8, 2010, Mayor Segarra informed Rosie that as of July 9, 2010 his "service as Corporation Counsel is terminated". Long overdue, but finally common sense prevailed and Rose was done. Yes, long overdue, but John Rose has been terminated

Rose Segarra Letters

Now that Rose is gone, it is time for someone to start culling the files from the (less than)Rosie John Rose years. A couple of immediate cases come to mind.

First off would be any case with the three magic letters of FOI associated with them. At the very least, tens of thousands of dollars have been spent on nonsense FOI appeals and hearings. Not just FOI requests I had made, but numerous others including the Hartford Courant and a group consisting of writers for a prisoners newsletter. In that case thousands of dollars have been spent to fight a fee for copies of under $30.00. The waiver of the fee appears legitimate because the complainants could prove "indigence", as allowed under the FOI laws.

Another case that I have written quite a bit about is the Dan Nolan termination. Any lawyer would have, or should have, advised their client that this was a loser of a termination. An Iraq and Afghanistan war veteran, an exemplary member of the Hartford Fire Department who had been firefighter of the year in the past, all of a sudden terminated. And the terrible conduct he participated in? He encouraged fire department recruits to participate in charity events. He disciplined recruits as a total group to encourage teamwork.How awful!

What may prove more even more interesting though is potential testimony on information that has come to light in the last couple months. I had received information regarding a situation that was reported several years ago in the Hartford Courant about the "burnmaster". It had been reported that Teale and two other officers working at the Hartford Training Academy had received payments from neighboring towns for using Hartford's fire academy facilities.

Teale and the two others pocketed the money paid to them, rather than pass it through to the City of Hartford. When the Courant's article came to light, apparently the Teale Trio were forced to repay the City about $3,000. Teale paid the re-imbursement for all three members of the Teale trio back to the City. Apparently during that period, the City was adding laser eye surgery as a benefit for police and firefighters. By this time, Teale was acting Chief of the Department and for some reason he met with Dr. Fichman of the Fichman Eye Center. During that meeting, Dr. Fichman handed Chief Teale a check for the amount he had paid to the City and Teale accepted the check.

I have attempted to contact both Teale and Dr. Fichman to get their version of this payoff, but neither would comment. Teale angrily stormed away when I asked him for his version, and Dr. Fichman's son returned my call with a "no comment". Repeated calls to the senior Fichman were never returned.

I would hope that a union attorney representing Nolan would raise the question of this payoff during a Labor Board hearing. It seems rather ironic that Chief Teale would terminate Nolan for having recruits get involved in charity events when he was in fact taking potential payoffs for himself.

The only issue here is that the new Corporation Counsel, Sandra Kee-Borges, was also the City Manager at the time this scandal first surfaced and was responsible for disciplining Teale at the time. I would hope she can look at the facts objectively and realize that this is a loser of a case and if it eventually ends in front of a jury, it won't look favorable for the City.

I did speak to a source in the Connecticut States Attorney's Office and explained the facts as I knew them. They informed me that for Teale, or any public official to accept a check made out to them under such circumstances would be illegal. Fortunately for Teale, they said the statute of limitations would have expired by now. I'm sure there will be some "silver tongue" explanation from Teale, but is he willing to offer proof ?

Settle with Nolan now and avoid paying any larger settlement than we already are going to have to pay.

Another interesting case currently under appeal was the termination of a Tax Office employee branded a thief by her bosses in the Finance Department. The only problem was that the Labor Board didn't see any evidence of her being a thief, the City and her boss Lydia Rosario couldn't provide any evidence of her being a thief, and the Board of Mediation and Arbitration ordered the employee, Vilma Rivera-Saez reinstated to her position. The City under the direction of Rosie's legal masters has refused and is appealing the order.

One of the big problems was the fact of documented thefts from the Tax Office, but the evidence didn't point to Rivera-Saez, who the City labeled a "thief" according to the arbitration award. Testimony actually pointed to another individual who apparently is related to Deputy Finance Director through marriage to Rosario's niece, who also by coincidence works in the Finance Department.

Another stinker of a case headed to , I predict, a big payout if the City continues to appeal.

Here's the Arbitration Award for Vilma Rivera-Saez:
Vilma Rivera-saez Arbitration Award

And finally, to end this for today is the pending appeal of another Labor Board decision regarding Hartford Police Officer Matthew Secore. Secore was terminated after he struck the nephew of former Mayor Perez after Perez's nephew brutally attacked Secore's brother.

The Labor Board determined that termination was too severe a punishment and ruled that Secore should be re-instated less a 90 day suspension. The City has refused to abide by the decision and the case is winding its way through the courts. Several attorneys I have spoke with tell me that the appeal has little or no chance of winning and Secore will most likely prevail in the end. The short version is that these decisions are very difficult to overturn unless the City can prove wrongdoing on the part of a hearing officer. There have been no claims of any wrongdoing.

It also appears that the punishment served to Secore doesn't fit the past practice of the degrees of punsihment. As an example, Secore was honest from the start and didn't try to deny the incident. On the other hand, an Officer who was involved in an incident where she shot an individual with a less than lethal shot-gun blast and initially lied to investigators, has since been promoted to the rank of Lieutenant. This as well as other incidents appear to have figured into the Labor Board's decision.

This is another one to settle and get Officer Secore back to work as the Labor Board ordered.

Matthew Secore's Arbitration Award is below:

Secore Arbitration Award

In a cash strapped City we can hardly afford to pursue cases and appeals that are clear losers and have already cost the taxpayers of Hartford enough just in legal fees, never mind the potential jury awards down the road.

Labeling an employee a thief without documentation,as the Deputy Director of Finance Lydia Rosario allegedly did most likely will not sit well with a jury. Signing a letter of termination to a respected veteran, Deputy Chief Dan Nolan with one hand while having the other out to accept a check from Dr. Fichman I'm sure will not impress a jury. And the photos of Matthew Secore's brother Slade Secore after his severe beating by Reuben Perez will most likely not sit very well with a jury either.

Common sense should prevail and a sense of justice should prevail in the new Office of the Corporation Counsel.


Bruce Rubenstein said...

Kevin...i couldnt agree more...lets hope that our new Mayor and new Corporation Counsel see this post by you and start rectifying the wrongs.

Captain said...

The information about Teale is interesting. He told the Courant when he annouced his retirement that his decision to fire Dan Nolan was based on the facts. Hmm... What facts??? I predict that when the labor board decision on Dan Nolan's case is announced, the silver tongued Teale will be no where to be found.

Connor said...

This posting further underscores what I and others have already said. Perez's soldiers that remain employed by the city must be let go. If you look @ the state labor bd decision 2 names will jump out @ you: Santiago Malave and Ivan Ramos. These 2 I believe hardly ever prevail in cases brought forward by the HMEA union. As opposed to other unions, HMEA is slow to file @ the state; that is, HMEA tries to work it out with the city before resorting to state intervention in order to save both parties time and money. HMEA after all represents primarily the mid and upper managers in the city. We can only hope that Mayor Segarra acts swiftly to replace Perez's remaining foot soldiers so that the city may actually progress and not waste its limited resources on unnecessary law suits and state labor bd cases.

Bruce RUbenstein said...

Good post Connor and it is one that I completely agree with.As Mayor Segarra makes his rounds and assesses someone as "bad for the city" in any respect,hopefully that person will be replaced by someone more competant.

Anonymous said...

you can only see the odd-numbered pages of the decision for Vilma...please post all pages...thx

Anonymous said...

"Secore was terminated after he struck the nephew of former Mayor Perez after Perez's nephew brutally attacked Secore's brother."

Not too biased are we?

Anonymous said...

and another thing...

What makes anyone think that "Segarra is making his rounds." to get rid of people who are "bad for the city"? Half of the names that have been listed on this blog as bad apples are not direct appointees and are probably union folk that no one can just let go.

Santiago can be let go but the City just announced a bunch of new hires. You think any Mayor looking to get rid of the Dir of HR would allow that same person to spearhead the first City new hires in years? I don't think so.

Oscar said...

Finding someone "more competant than Malave shouldn't be much of a problem. He's just about useless.



It's my blog and I can be biased, but I try not to. Simply look at the pictures taken of both parties and you would be hard pressed to find a mark on Reuben Perez. On the other hand, Slade Secore's eyes were swollen shut as well as bruising on and about his face, I believe he suffered a broken eye socket as well as numerous other injuries. That qualifies as a "brutal" beating in my book.

Anonymous said...

Kevin, you are right, Secore's brother was beaten brutally and severely. Stop gaps were in place to prevent Secore from striking the Mayor's nephew, simply put, those measures failed Secore. And the Sergeant who let Secore in the cell?- he only took a slap on the wrist (5 day suspension) on his way out the retirement door. But the question is, who decided to appeal the Secore (and Murtha)case after his arbitration award? I believe it was the department head (Roberts and McKoy)who have final say and would not let him back on the force. The chief could take Secore (and Murtha) back anytime but refuses. His and McKoy’s gaffs have already and will continue to cost the city hundreds of thousands of dollars. Secore (and Murtha) is already going to collect his back salary. Every day that passes he is banking a days pay, at the city's expense. You hit the nail on the head with Secore and Nolan. Wait until the Murtha award, wowzers$$!!! I fear that some of the junior corp lawyers have John Rose arrogance- and the same old issues will stick around. Somebody should FOI how much the city has spent fighting Murtha (they are paying an outside law firm to handle that case and other PD cases$$$) Better yet, somebody should FOI how much the city/PD has lost in Arbitration awards and the cost fighting them. Very interesting. The current Chief and McKoy have a very loose understanding of Labor and civil law, and the city pays dearly for it every day.

Anonymous said...

Lydia Rosaria has cost the city huge money with employee cases against her. She should go along with Santiago Malave.